Welcome to Executive Benefit Plans, Inc.


Main Link Column
Select this link Retirement Plans
Select this link Strategies
Select this link Employee Benefits
Select this link Individual Benefits
Select this link Participant Info
Select this link White Papers
Select this link Consulting Service
Select this link Proposal Request
Select this link Administration
Select this link Contact
Select this link News
Select this link Blog
Select this link Home

Plan Insight

JULY 2010 Newsletter

Measuring The Impact Of 401(k) Fee Disclosures

Starting soon, 401(k) plan sponsors will be required to tell employees clearly just how much they pay in fees. In turn, investment firms will have to spell out for plan sponsors what they shell out in charges. How might all this candor about costs change the settled world of 401(k) plans?

By one estimate, fees could plunge $700 million per year as plans bargain harder, buy services à la carte, and replace mutual funds with less-expensive institutional funds and separate accounts. Benefits officers might be swamped with employees incensed at 401(k) charges. And recordkeepers could find themselves having to frantically rewrite computer programs.

Or, then again, nothing much might happen. Participants still won’t bother to read 401(k) material, and hence will continue to ignore fees. And retooling computer systems might cost recordkeepers only a few dollars per investor.  Whatever the case, the 401(k) realm will know soon enough: The Department of Labor hopes to issue plan participant rules by this summer, and has released a plan sponsor–service provider version.

“For individuals, it’s really important to understand how their account balance is affected by fees,” says Phyllis Borzi, the DoL assistant secretary who supervises the Employee Benefit Security Administration, which oversees 401(k)s.

Without Washington’s saying a word, annual fees for the most common 401(k) funds slid from an average of almost 66 basis points in 1997 to 54 in 2008, according to the Investment Company Institute. One reason: Plans can negotiate better rates as they grow. In addition, plans are shopping around for lower-priced funds. Lawsuits alleging overcharging have also spurred closer scrutiny by employers.

There are three basic 401(k) levies: investment management fees, fees for special services like loans, and administrative fees covering recordkeeping, accounting, compliance and other plan wide work. Participants pay the first two in all cases, and in 59 percent of plans they also fork over the administrative fee, according to consultant Hewitt Associates of Lincolnshire, Illinois.

Payment information must already be included in fund prospectuses and may also appear in plan descriptions or on employers’ Web sites. Yet most experts say that few employees understand what they’re paying, because it typically comes out of returns. “There are participants who don’t realize they’re paying a thing,” says Robert Liberto, a senior vice president at New York benefits consultant firm Segal Co.

Many plan sponsors, especially at smaller companies, aren’t much better informed. “A lot of employers think recordkeeping is free,” because it’s wrapped up with other fees, Borzi says. Particularly mysterious is the fee-splitting arrangement called revenue sharing — the fees that outside funds pay to a recordkeeper to be included in a plan. The DoL worries that such arrangements hide a conflict of interest.

Some in the industry are skeptical of the whole thrust of disclosure. The 2008 proposals were going to require so much information that it’s not likely participants would have read it, says Robyn Credico, national director of defined-contribution consulting for New York consulting firm Towers Watson.  By contrast, most consultants and plan sponsors, too, want a detailed fee breakdown. Employers, says Hewitt’s director of retirement research, Pamela Hess, should know the answers to such questions as “How does my vendor make money on rollovers?” Nevertheless, as Segal’s Liberto points out: “Providers have been reluctant to give this information. It identifies the significant amount of money they’re receiving.”

David Wray, president of the Profit-Sharing/401(k) Council of America, says a detailed breakdown may not matter much for most employees, who have become less active in reading the fine print. With the advent of automatic enrollment and target-date funds, he says, participants are saying, “Make the decision for me.”

Retirement Plans

Select this link Consulting Services

Select this link Qualified Plans

   Select this link Savings Calculator

   Select this link  401k

   Select this link Safe Harbor 401k

   Select this link Roth 401k

   Select this link SIMPLE 401k

   Select this link Profit Sharing

   Select this link Money Purchase

   Select this link Defined Benefit

   Select this link Cash Balance

   Select this link Successor Plan Rule

   Select this link IRC 401(a)

   Select this link ERISA 404(c)

   Select this link Prohibitive Transactions

   Select this link Fiduciaries

   Select this link Contribution Limits

   Select this link Controlled Groups

Select this link Other Plans

   Select this link IRAs

   Select this link 419(e)

   Select this link SEPs

   Select this link SARSEPs

   Select this link SIMPLE IRA

Other Links

Select this link Tests

    Select this link ACP Test

    Select this link ADP Test

Select this link Restatements

Select this link Amendments

Select this link Mistakes

Select this link Catch-up

Select this link Funding Limits

Select this link EGTRRA Q&A

Select this link Conduit IRA

Select this link Pricing

Select this link Quote

Select this link White Papers

Select this link FAQs

Select this link Glossary



Information is provided for review and consideration only. Please consult legal and tax advisors for practical advice pertaining to your business and personal situations.

Material in our newsletter may have been extracted in whole or in part from the IRS Employee Plans publication, and the presence of IRS material does not constitute or imply the endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the IRS of any opinions, products, or services offered by the sponsor of this web page or document.

This page was last reviewed and/or updated on Friday, July 03, 2015 05:21 PM


Privacy Statement - Executive Benefit Plans, Inc. Copyright 1996 - 2015 All Rights Reserved - Legal Statement
Website Powered by UHSystems